SNAP Recipients Sue to Block All State Soda, Candy Purchase Bans

This article was originally published in Bloomberg Law. Read it here.

A group of federal food aid recipients and convenience stores are suing the Trump administration to block a policy allowing 18 states to restrict the spending of grocery benefits on sugary foods or beverages.

The initiative under fire is a key aspect of Health Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr.’s Make America Healthy Again agenda and represents one of the administration’s most definitive policies targeting the food and beverage sector to date.

Plaintiffs who on Wednesday brought the proposed class action in the US District Court for the District of Columbia are represented by the same legal groups that in June convinced a federal judge to vacate purchase restrictions affecting the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program in five states on the grounds that the US Department of Agriculture exceeded its authority in approving the restrictions. The Trump administration subsequently appealed the ruling in August.

“Today we are asking the court to extend the protection every SNAP recipient and their families already won to every family in the remaining states with food purchase restrictions. The legal and factual issues are identical to those the court has already determined,” said Jeffrey Shinder, a partner at Shinder Cantor Lerner. The firm is representing the plaintiffs alongside the National Center for Law and Economic Justice.

The lawsuit alleges that approving the purchase restrictions exceeded the USDA’s statutory authority, was arbitrary and capricious, and violated the public notice requirements of the Administrative Procedure Act.

Plaintiffs argue the department relied on a provision under the Food and Nutrition Act of 2008 that allows state pilot projects to improve SNAP benefit delivery efficiency, rather than a more stringent provision designed to improve SNAP recipients’ health and nutrition.

Kennedy, speaking at a Milken Institute conference on Nov. 13, touted the bans as a key method to combating rising chronic disease rates and blamed sugary products for giving children diabetes.

The department also reversed its previous position opposing such purchase restrictions with no explanation, and belatedly sought public comment on pilots in eight states after the restrictions had already taken effect.

“Doing notice and comment after your waiver is already up and running, it doesn’t comply with the regulation. It also doesn’t make a lot of practical sense,” Shinder said in an interview.

Similar to the first lawsuit that successfully challenged these restrictions, many of the named plaintiffs are SNAP recipients with health conditions such as diabetes or hypoglycemia who alleged they rely on the restricted items to manage low blood sugar.

The South Carolina Convenience and Petroleum Marketers Association, which represents convenience stores and gas stations, is also a plaintiff. Many of the group’s members are SNAP retailers who face billions of dollars in compliance costs and risk losing business if the USDA involuntarily removes them from the program for selling a restricted item, the lawsuit said.

The group is the first industry stakeholder to bring their concerns with the policy to court, though dozens of food companies and trade groups representing the sector have challenged the administration’s authority to restrict SNAP purchases in opposition letters to officials. Many of the restricted products are sold by the food sector’s biggest companies including The Coca-Cola Co., PepsiCo Inc., General Mills Inc., andThe Kraft Heinz Co.

The estimated class exceeds 11 million people, as restrictions in 18 states cover nearly a third of the nation’s 36.1 million individuals receiving SNAP, though they don’t kick in until 2027 in five states and until 2028 in Nevada, according to USDA data.

While the exact scope of the restrictions varies by state, initial research by the National Bureau of Economic Research suggests the policy drove a 12% reduction in purchases of restricted drinks by SNAP households.

Meyer v. Rollins, Dist. Ct. U.S. D.C., No. 1:26-cv-04079, complaint filed 11/18/26.